Spotlight On
Back to contentsUNPACKING PADDOCK TO PLATE
As the customer continues to evolve and become more interested in where their meal is coming from, terms like ‘paddock to plate’ and ‘farm to fork’ have emerged as the serviceable catch phrase to encompass this ideology. The internal logic holds true, every item on the plate has originated from a farm somewhere.
However, when we begin to unpack the concept and how it is often promoted, the sincerity of the claim is put to test with few able to truly claim a paddock to plate offering when considering the distance between the plate, the paddock and the multiple organisations involved between the two.
For this piece, I wanted to explore different venues that do indeed reflect the true nature of paddock to plate – where the product used in-venue was actually produced onsite. The supply chains in these instances are not just processing and transport; they are very much a quality chain of expertise, of vision and passion and demonstrate different levels of scale.
Lisa and Andrew Margan established Margan Estate in the Broke Fordwich sub-region of the Hunter Valley in 1996. They are ostensibly a wine brand but also a well-established part of wine tourism in the area with a highly regarded on-farm restaurant and event space doing around 290 covers a weekend.
As well as their wine, they manage a one-acre kitchen garden, orchard free-range chickens, beehives, olive groves and estate reared Suffolk and Dorper lambs.
Lisa was inspired to produce her own lamb after a lunch using a neighbour’s lamb alongside produce from their own kitchen garden.
“I pulled together this lunch of beautiful spring lamb, new potatoes, all sorts of salad out of the garden and wine that we had made and I just thought, what a wonderful thing this would be and imagine being able to replicate it larger scale for our Margan guests.”
Their lamb project started about 15 years ago and they now manage a flock of up to 50 head at any one time. The sheep rotate through pastures and vines on the estate, operating like ‘little lawnmowers’ and play a role in the company’s environmental management program.
Margan Estate is on track to become organically certified and carbon neutral and the sheep are an important part of that closed loop, keeping the grass down between the vines and adding nutrient value at the same time. It’s about reducing our impact on the environment and leaving the property in good shape for our children,” Lisa said.
Joey Ingram is head chef at Margan and seized the chance to move from the city with his family just over a year ago. He comes to the Hunter via two of Sydney’s great restaurants, Tetsuya’s and Balzac. Joey says that Fergus Henderson’s Nose to Tail Eating was what led him to Matt Kemp at Balzac and fostered his love of whole beast cooking.
“Matt was buying whole carcases in the city way before anyone else; it was part of his English kitchen tradition.” Ingram says there was no ‘ethos’ and laughs as he imagines what Kemp actually said about such ephemeral things. “It was more about showing the skill of the chef on one plate. Using the whole thing was just good kitchen management.”
The traditional butchery skills learned under Kemp allowed him to develop his agri-dining style. In practice, this concept means around 90 percent of what Ingram serves over his kitchen pass comes from the estate. His main-focus is the one-hectare organic garden that dictates his five course set menu.
“I think that the guests can see the connection, they get to do a tour of the garden, they get to meet the lamb, see the chickens and to see the vegetables that they’re about to eat. All of that ties into what we try to do here, which is estate grown, estate made.”
The drought and 2020 fire-storm showed that there are challenges to establishing such an ethos and it is about fitting into the seasons and the natural production cycle. Ingram’s vineyard manager tells him when the lambs are ready and he fits in around that.
“It’s not really up to me, he’ll tell me that there’s some lambs going to the abattoirs next week and so I’ll need to be ready to break them down and get them onto a plate.”
The lambs are taken from Margan to the abattoir in Kurri Kurri where they are processed and chilled down overnight. Ingram’s butcher then picks them up in a food grade truck and brings them back.
“We’ll generally hang them for anywhere from seven to 10 days in our custom built dry ageing room and from there we can begin to break it down as we need it and hang some things longer. We use a combination of primary and secondary cuts and try to get a good amount of each part of the animal through the dish.”
When asked about the viability of their paddock to plate model – Lisa says it is more about the fact that it suits their operation and they have the space to do it.
“Paddock to plate isn’t going to be for everyone and it is hard to say that we do it for a cost advantage. I think it’s more a break even proposition but it suits us and it is more about the customer being able to connect with that story and to enjoy estate-reared lamb alongside estate-grown produce and wines,” Margan concludes.
Packaging tsar, Charles Hanna OAM, purchased historic Colly Creek in 2005. Established by squatter’s rights in 1830, the property was an important foundation acreage for the Liverpool Ranges. Originally clear felled by axe, it took the vision of the Hanna Pastoral Group to muster the property back to the original 5,500 acres that time and hardship had scattered.
Colly Creek has been developed into a property specialising in purebred Angus cattle with a focus on producing the best eating quality product for the restaurant trade. 10 years ago, Charles purchased the nearby Willow Tree Inn as a destination for his award-winning beef – and put considerable energy and investment into establishing a destination for locals and travellers.
Originally a fairly run-down cattle-town watering hole, the Hanna’s have added luxury rooms and a steak house called Graze. The contemporary charcoal painted inn, situated on the New England Highway, attracts a large audience who come to dine on the house-aged Colly Creek steaks and experience the bustling village of Willow Tree.
Managing Director of Hanna Pastoral Sam Hanna, is passionate about the process and takes great pride in what the family are achieving.
“We do everything onsite, from genetics and breeding to backgrounding and finishing at our own boutique feedlot operation. We’re constantly looking to improve genetics, employing the best animal and pasture management practices and utilising the benefit of an onsite finishing program where we can control what we feed the animals for the end product,” Sam said.
Laconic Nick Brien and his wife Leonie are quintessential cattle people, big hats and bigger hearts – happier on the back of a horse than off one. They manage Colly Creek, alongside long-term stockmen Roger Barnett and Les Palmer. While typically modest, you sense their pride, deep understanding of the land and their love of the cattle industry.
“Here, the animals come first. We are very much about low stress stock handling which means calmer animals, more productivity and more comfortable surrounds for the cattle so they do better, which means better eating quality beef at the end of the day,” Nick said.
With the improved season, Colly Creek expects around 700 calves this season. The calves enjoy the benefit of full pastures until weaning at around 8-10 months; then once they reach target weight, they head to the boutique onsite feedlot for finishing. Here they will go through a ‘backgrounding’ process that slowly introduces grain to their diet and establishes them in low-stress social groups prior to entering the feedlot.
Once in the feedlot they transition to a high protein, barley based diet with the cattle’s appetite dictating the ration. In around 120 days they will reach the target 600-650kg at which point they will be sent to the abattoir for processing.
“The 120 day grain finish that we put on the cattle is really important to the consistency of the product and to make sure that we get that intramuscular fat and fat cover for the 45 day dry ageing that ultimately benefits the eating quality of the product.”
“We probably have one of the smallest operational footprints in terms of paddock to plate – Colly Creek is two kilometres from the hotel. It’s not just about the provenance; it also allows us to serve country portions of a high quality product at country prices,” Sam said.
Each month, the best 25 animals are selected for the restaurant where two dry ageing rooms and a thorough menu ensure the whole carcase is utilised. Head chef Ben Davies says the paddock to plate operation is a dream come true for any chef and guests love the fact that all the beef served at the restaurant comes from within two kilometers of the hotel.
“These cattle are purely bred for Graze and when you’ve got such a beautiful product, you don’t really need to mess around with it. We’ve got a dry ageing room onsite and we bring 10 bodies up a week from there to hang in our restaurant dry-ageing room so people can see them.”
“The prime cuts are 10 percent of a body so you have to be a little bit more creative to use the whole carcase. The lovely thing here is that it’s a pub so in addition to our dry-aged steaks, we mince and dice a lot to make pies, burgers, steak sandwiches so everyone can enjoy the Colly Creek experience.”
“We braise our briskets down, we do our own beef ribs, we smoke all the meats for our charcuterie, we make all our own sausages, kabana, chorizo, salamis – and that’s the way we use the whole body, by educating people about all the different cuts,” Davies said.
Burnt Ends at Beerfarm is a collaboration situated in Metricup in the south west of Western Australia. The craft brewery and smokehouse sits on 160 acres where they graze around 70 head of prime Angus cattle.
The team at Burnt Ends, executive chef Eileen Booth, pitmaster Nathan Booth and venue manager Emma Locke believe utilising their own livestock is key for creating a premium end-product.
“We are passionate and humble people. Honesty and integrity is at the heart of everything we do and our ethos is encapsulated by our brand tagline ‘established for the future’. We are always striving to be sustainable and accountable for all procedures we have at the farm. Our eye is not on the past but the future,” Booth says.
As working partners with a brewery, this ethos is put into practice. Spent grain and yeasts from the brew process is fed to the cattle and provides extra proteins and nutrients while adding to the flavour of the meat; and acting as a supplement in the dryer months when less grass is available. Diatomaceous Earth, used in the filtering process for beer, is mixed in with the grain and the aids in controlling gut parasites. In addition, the yeast that has been filtered out contains lots of vitamins and minerals that have a positive impact on the cattle’s gut health.”
“In most breweries, these products are considered waste products but we consider them a major part of our cattle’s lifecycle which keeps them as healthy as they can be. This relationship between the brewery and the cattle helps manage our carbon footprint associated with traditional grazing practices and beer production. The happier and healthier we can keep the cattle and their gut, the happier we can keep ours.”
“Growing our own beef gives us greater clarity in the processes, enabling us to have more control of the end product. We know what they are fed, where they roam and have a very clear insight into a supply chain that has minimal impact on the animal. At this time, we cannot process our cattle on site so therefore we cannot deliver the true paddock to plate ethos, although this is in the plans for the future,” Locke said.
Beerfarm purchase their cattle as weaners, generally running around 70 head at a time at different age and weight groups for a consistent rotation of supply for the farm and their butcher.
“We aim for each animal to be between 300-350 kg on average when they go to be processed. This weight allows enough time to get the necessary fat and consistency in the size of cuts we use. It also minimises wastage as once the animal gets too big, there is a significant amount of extra trim that can’t be used.”
Once at weight, the cattle are sent to the abattoir and then to Bullsbrook Gourmet Butchers where they are hung and aged for a minimum of two weeks. Currently they send four animals per fortnight to cater for the growing demand. Burnt Ends receives the prime cuts – including a 13 week aged prime rib – and secondary cuts as well as four different types of sausages alongside mince and bones for stock and jus.
Pitmaster Nathan Booth says one of the biggest challenges for the team is utilising the whole animal. To offset this and in line with their commitment to reducing waste, they have established a relationship with their butcher who is able to utilise much of the trim and secondary cuts for small goods.
“We strive to use many of the secondary cuts within our three menus however due to the varied demographic that visits our venue this can often be extremely challenging. Day to day in our current menu we utilise bolar blade and chuck in one of our favourite dishes – smoked chopped beef tostadas. The mince is also used for our Angus burgers, alongside the trim from our briskets and beef ribs before they are smoked.”
“Raise The Steaks on Friday nights is where we really flex our muscles and showcase our beef to a more controlled audience in a more intimate dining setting. Here we have an opportunity to use all the major prime cuts and also secondary cuts and this menu changes on a weekly basis.”
“Our Smoking Saturday’s menus have been gaining fast acknowledgement for the traditional BBQ and smoking methods we use, no shortcuts. We run a variety of dishes that come directly from the pits including brisket, beef ribs, our own links that change in flavour, tacos with our beef and full barbecue platters consisting of a little bit of everything.”
“We also sell a range of Beerfarm Bangers available to the public that have been packaged up for us by our butcher. Like anything, these processes take time and we are always striving to do and be better. We are working on our own bresaola, pastramis and jerky currently to optimise the use of the secondary cuts. This is something we are very passionate about,” said Booth.
Amelia Park is the boutique brand of V&V Walsh based in Bunbury, Western Australia. Established by Vern and Jean Walsh in 1957, V&V Walsh grew under the guidance of two generations of the Walsh family from humble beginnings in a butcher’s shop.
A much larger scale production, the Amelia Park model draws on farmers across the South West of Western Australia who pasture feed to a strict quality criteria. The stock are lot fed according to conditions of the season and feedlot finished to ensure a consistent quality product all year round.
The state-of-the-art processing facility can process 5000 sheep per day and approximately half of this is boned and packed on-site. In addition, it can process a further 400 cattle per day, with the ability to bone and process 300 beef carcases. The abattoir employs more than 1000 people and produces more than 40 million kilograms of meat products annually, making it one of Australia’s largest meat processing plants.
Located amongst the vineyards of Amelia Park Wines in the Wilyabrup sub-region of Margaret River, Blair and Renee Allen have run the award-winning Amelia Park Restaurant since 2017. Allen’s jarrah-fired kitchen relies on local produce including some from the restaurant’s own garden with the core offering being Amelia Park branded lamb and beef.
Being part of an integrated boutique brand allows chef Allen the perception and marketing benefits of a paddock to plate ethos without the challenges of utilising the entire carcase.
“At Amelia Park Restaurant we generally showcase a primary and a secondary cut of lamb, generally the rack and the square cut shoulder. With the beef, we use the strip loin that we get in whole bone-in and dry age for four weeks in our dry ageing fridge. The slow roasted lamb shoulder is by far our most popular dish and what we are known for and we sell between 80 and 120 shoulders a week.”
“We have a very diverse customer base at the restaurant and our menu reflects this and is very flexible. Amelia Park lamb and beef has never let me down, it is always fresh and full of flavour and has been the cornerstone of all my menus over a long period of time,” Renee said.